← Return to homeCultureQuietly considered
Culture

The Christmas Advert Is Not About Television Anymore

John Lewis has divided opinion, M&S has found favour and Aldi is still betting on a carrot. Why do Britain’s retailers continue to invest so heavily in the Christmas advert?

By Taste Makers9 November 2026
The Christmas Advert Is Not About Television Anymore

By early November, Britain’s Christmas adverts have already been released, reviewed and ranked. Soundtracks have been identified, budgets questioned and winners declared, often before most people have bought their first present.

For much of the past two decades, John Lewis has set the terms of the competition. Its annual film became something larger than retail marketing: a test of the national mood, delivered through emotional storytelling, an unlikely companion and a carefully chosen cover version.

Its twentieth campaign, Gloria and Pickles, has not received the universal affection the retailer might have wanted. Kristin Scott Thomas plays a grandmother who has lost confidence in choosing presents for her grandchildren. Critics have focused on the grand London home, the apparently ungrateful children and a version of Christmas that feels removed from the financial pressures facing many families.

That criticism is understandable, but the response is not as straightforward as social media suggests. While one analysis found that half of the online conversation was negative, audience testing awarded the advert 5.6 stars, John Lewis’s strongest score since 2019. The film may have divided opinion, but it has certainly not been ignored.

M&S has taken a lighter and more commercially direct route. The Home of Christmas brings together food, fashion, beauty and home in one campaign, with James Norton playing an incognito Santa. It is warm, funny and filled with products, yet avoids feeling like a three-minute catalogue.

Early audience research placed it ahead of the other supermarket campaigns, with 74 per cent of respondents saying they liked or loved it. The advert reflects a retailer that appears increasingly comfortable with itself. Food remains central to the M&S Christmas, but fashion, beauty and home no longer feel like supporting departments.

Elsewhere, Tesco has turned a misplaced grocery delivery into a story about rekindled friendship. The Wrong Address uses a familiar festive crisis to position the supermarket as the retailer that helps Christmas happen.

Aldi, meanwhile, has returned to Kevin the Carrot for a tenth year. Familiarity is central to the idea. Kevin now operates less like an advertising character and more like a piece of retail intellectual property, extending into social content, merchandise and toys.

Each campaign takes a different route, but all are attempting to answer the same question. How does a retailer remain emotionally relevant when shopping has become increasingly practical?

The IPA’s 2026 Christmas Consumer Report found that 45 per cent of consumers expect to feel financially anxious this Christmas. At the same time, almost half say they do not intend to cut back on any part of the celebration. Shoppers are looking for discounts, free delivery and practical presents, but remain reluctant to surrender the idea of Christmas as a period of indulgence.

The Christmas advert allows retailers to navigate that contradiction. It establishes a mood before the promotional emails, loyalty prices and Black Friday offers begin competing for attention.

What we continue to call the Christmas television advert is also no longer confined to television. John Lewis will show its campaign across ITV, Channel 4 and Sky, but also Netflix, Prime Video, Disney+, YouTube, TikTok and other social platforms. M&S is extending its story through cinema, outdoor advertising, influencers, recipes and digital shopping tools.

The expensive film has become the centre of a much larger system. Retailers do not need everybody to watch it at the same time. They need enough people to encounter it somewhere, discuss it elsewhere and recognise it when the campaign returns.

UK advertising investment during the final quarter of 2026 is forecast to reach a record £14 billion. Social media, retail media and addressable television are growing more quickly than traditional broadcast advertising, but the large Christmas production continues because it gives those fragmented channels one shared idea.

M&S may have captured the mood most successfully. John Lewis has captured the argument. Aldi owns familiarity, while Tesco has found warmth in festive disorder.

The commercial winner will not necessarily be the advert people claim to like most. It will be the one that returns to mind when they choose where to buy the turkey, the cashmere scarf or the final present.

Even while comparing prices, collecting loyalty points and waiting for Black Friday, we still want someone to make Christmas feel larger than a shopping list.

Continue reading

Quietly Noted

Short dispatches on people, places and things worth knowing.

Return to the latest stories →